The offer with the bigger headline number often pays less once you add benefits and count the hours. An hourly rate and an annual salary use different units, so you need to put both on the same scale before you decide. These 7 steps take about 30 minutes with both offer letters in front of you.
Get every number in writing
Offer letters usually show the rate or salary and little else. Ask the recruiter or hiring manager for the rest before you compare anything. Tick each item as you collect it for both jobs.
Recruiters expect these questions at the offer stage. Asking for figures in writing also gives you a record if the details change after you start.
Convert both offers to a yearly figure
A full time year is 2,080 hours: 40 hours a week for 52 weeks. Use it to turn the hourly rate into a yearly figure, or the salary into an hourly one.
Rate × 2,080$32 × 2,080 = $66,560
Salary ÷ 2,080$68,000 ÷ 2,080 = $32.69
On these headline numbers, the salary looks $1,440 a year better. That’s only the starting point. Use paid weeks for the hourly offer: if holidays and leave are unpaid, take those weeks out first. The hourly to salary calculator and salary to hourly calculator do this in either direction.
Add overtime to the hourly offer
Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, non exempt employees earn at least 1.5 times their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. Most hourly jobs are non exempt. A salaried employee can be exempt only if they earn at least $684 a week ($35,568 a year) and their duties meet the federal test.
Count overtime only if it’s regular. Use last year’s average for the role, and multiply by the weeks you’ll work.
| Overtime at $32 an hour ($48 rate) | Per week | Over 48 weeks |
|---|---|---|
| 2 hours a week | $96 | $4,608 |
| 4 hours a week | $192 | $9,216 |
| 6 hours a week | $288 | $13,824 |
| 10 hours a week | $480 | $23,040 |
For tax years 2025 through 2028, eligible non exempt workers can also deduct the premium half of qualified overtime pay on their federal return, up to $12,500. The overtime calculator handles time and a half, double time and daily overtime.
Put a dollar figure on the benefits
2 benefits change most comparisons: what you pay for health insurance, and what the employer adds to your retirement account. Price both for each offer.
Health insurance
KFF’s 2025 survey puts the average employer plan premium at $9,325 a year for single cover and $26,993 for family cover. Workers paid an average of $1,440 and $6,850 of that. Your share is the number to compare: subtract 12 months of your premium from each offer’s value.
Retirement match
Multiply the match by your pay. Vanguard data puts the average employer match at 4.6% of pay, with a median of 4%. A 4% match on $68,000 adds $2,720 a year. Check the vesting schedule too: if the match vests over 3 years and you leave after 1, you may lose it.
Paid days off
Paid leave affects both pay and hours. For an hourly job, paid days keep your pay at 2,080 hours. For any job, more days off mean fewer hours worked, which raises your value per hour in step 6.
Count the hours you’ll work
Take the weekly hours from step 1 and multiply them by the weeks you’ll work after paid holidays and leave. 20 days off is 4 weeks, which leaves 48.
Yearly hours worked, 48 working weeks
A salaried job at 50 hours a week takes 480 more hours a year than one at 40. That’s 12 extra 40 hour weeks for the same salary. See how many work hours are in 2027 for the full calendar.
Divide total value by hours worked
Here are both offers with every number from steps 1 to 5. Offer A is hourly and non exempt. Offer B is salaried and exempt.
- Base pay (2,080 paid hours)
- $66,560
- Overtime (4 hrs × 48 weeks × $48)
- $9,216
- 3% retirement match
- $2,273
- Minus health premium ($200 a month)
- $2,400
- Total yearly value
- $75,649
- Hours (44 a week × 48 weeks)
- 2,112
- Salary
- $68,000
- Overtime (exempt)
- $0
- 4% retirement match
- $2,720
- Minus health premium ($120 a month)
- $1,440
- Total yearly value
- $69,280
- Hours (45 a week × 47.4 weeks)
- 2,133
Offer A is worth $6,369 more a year and pays $3.34 more per hour worked, even though Offer B had the higher headline number and better benefits. Offer B includes 23 days off (15 leave plus 8 holidays), which is why its hours are spread over 47.4 weeks.
What changes the answer
- The overtime stops. Offer A drops to $66,157 a year at 1,920 hours. Offer B is now worth $3,123 more a year, while Offer A still pays more per hour ($34.46 against $32.48).
- Offer B runs 40 hours a week. Its hours fall to 1,896 and its value per hour rises to $36.54, so Offer B wins on both measures.
- You need family health cover. Ask for the family premium at both jobs. A gap of $300 a month moves $3,600 a year between the offers.
Use the gap to negotiate
If you prefer Offer B for its hours, title or career path, the comparison tells you what to ask for. To match Offer A’s $35.82 per hour over 2,133 hours, Offer B’s salary would need to rise to about $74,848.
You can also close the gap without a salary change:
- Ask for a written cap on regular weekly hours, or extra paid days off.
- Ask the hourly employer for a higher rate if the overtime isn’t guaranteed.
- Ask for a signing bonus or an early raise review at 6 months.
To see what a raise adds per year and per hour, use the raise calculator.
Compare your 2 offers
Enter both offers. The defaults match the worked example, and the results update as you type.
Job offer comparison tool
Value per hour worked, with overtime, benefits and time off
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare an hourly wage to a salary?
Multiply the hourly rate by 2,080 for a full time year, add overtime and benefits, subtract your health premiums, then divide each offer’s total by the hours you’ll work. The higher value per hour pays more for your time.
What hourly rate equals a $70,000 salary?
$70,000 ÷ 2,080 hours is $33.65 an hour. If the salaried job runs 45 hours a week, the rate drops to $29.91.
What questions should I ask before accepting a job offer?
Ask about weekly hours, overtime eligibility, paid holidays and leave, your monthly health premium, the retirement match and vesting, pay frequency, and when the first raise review happens. The checklist in step 1 covers all of them.
How much is an employer 401(k) match worth?
Multiply the match percentage by your pay. A 4% match on $68,000 is $2,720 a year. Vanguard data puts the average match at 4.6% of pay and the median at 4%.
Is it better to be hourly or salaried?
Hourly usually pays more per hour when you work regular overtime. Salaried roles usually pay more when hours stay near 40 and benefits are strong. Our guide salary vs hourly: which pays more covers the trade offs in detail.
Calculators for your offer
More guides: how many working days are in 2027 and how many work hours are in 2027.
Sources
- KFF: 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey
- Kiplinger: Average 401(k) match, citing Vanguard How America Saves
- U.S. Department of Labor: Overtime pay
- Federal Register: Exemption salary levels, May 15, 2026
This guide gives estimates for planning. It isn’t financial, legal or tax advice. Overtime rules, benefits and taxes depend on your state, role and employer, so confirm details in writing before you accept an offer.