A $60 an hour contract sounds far better than a $75,000 salary. Once you subtract payroll tax, the benefits you give up, unpaid holidays and gaps between gigs, the gap shrinks fast. Here’s the full math for 1099 and W2 contracts.
These break even rates assume the job comes with $7,000 a year of employer health coverage and a 4% retirement match, and that the contractor bills 1,760 hours a year after 5 weeks of unpaid time off and 3 weeks between contracts. Change any of those and the answer moves, which is why the calculator below matters.
“Contractor” can mean 2 very different setups. A W2 contractor is an employee of a staffing agency, usually without benefits. A 1099 contractor is self employed and runs their own small business.
| Yearly figures | Salaried | W2 contract | 1099 contract |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid hours | 2,080 | 1,760 | 1,760 |
| Gross pay | $75,000 | $105,600 | $105,600 |
| Business expenses | $0 | $0 | $4,000 |
| Social Security and Medicare you pay | $5,738 | $8,078 | $14,356 |
| Employer health coverage | $7,000 | $0 | $0 |
| Retirement match (4%) | $3,000 | $0 | $0 |
| Comparable value | $79,263 | $97,522 | $87,244 |
| Compared with the salary | Baseline | +$18,259 | +$7,982 |
The contract wins here, but by far less than the $30,600 difference in gross pay. The 1099 contractor keeps only about $8,000 more, and that’s before counting the risk of a longer gap between contracts. Every extra unpaid week costs $2,400 at $60 an hour.
“Comparable value” counts the employer’s health and retirement contributions as part of the salaried package, since a contractor would have to pay for similar coverage and savings. Income tax is left out because both sides pay it at similar rates.
Divide the salary by 2,080 for its hourly rate, then multiply. For our $75,000 job: $36.06 × 1.52 = $54.72 for a 1099 contract. These multipliers come from our example; richer benefits, more paid time off or longer gaps push them higher.
| Salary | Hourly equivalent | W2 contract break even | 1099 contract break even |
|---|---|---|---|
| $50,000 | $24.04 | $32.45 | $36.54 |
| $60,000 | $28.85 | $38.94 | $43.85 |
| $75,000 | $36.06 | $48.68 | $54.81 |
| $100,000 | $48.08 | $64.90 | $73.08 |
| $125,000 | $60.10 | $81.13 | $91.35 |
Quick estimates using the 1.35 and 1.52 multipliers, so the $75,000 row differs from the exact figures by a few cents. Use the calculator for your own numbers. For a deeper look at setting a 1099 rate from scratch, see how to set your freelance hourly rate.
Enter the salaried offer on the left and the contract on the right. The calculator compares their real yearly value and finds the contract rate that breaks even.
Salary with benefits vs a W2 or 1099 contract
Compare your offers
Enter both offers to see which is worth more.
Self employment tax is 15.3% on 92.35% of net earnings; W2 contractors pay 7.65%. The Social Security wage base ($184,500 in 2026) is applied. Unpaid weeks include holidays, vacation and gaps between contracts. Overtime is paid at 1.5× for W2 contracts only. Income tax is not included.
Wondering whether a salaried role would even pay overtime? See exempt vs non exempt employees.
Know the rate that matches your current or offered salary before any conversation. It’s your floor.
A high rate with uncertain hours can be worth less than a lower rate for a full year.
On W2 contracts, check for health plans, paid holidays and overtime. On 1099 work, check payment terms and who covers expenses.
Short or uncertain contracts deserve a higher rate than long, stable ones.
Use the calculator above, and our guide to comparing an hourly offer with a salaried one.
Converting a contract to a salary? Agencies often charge clients well above what they pay the contractor. If a client wants to hire you directly, your break even rate gives you a strong anchor for the salary conversation.
Multiply the rate by the hours you’ll bill in a year, subtract business expenses and the extra payroll tax, then compare it with the salary plus the employer benefits you’d give up.
In our example, about $54.72 an hour for a 1099 contract and $48.77 for a W2 contract, with $7,000 of employer health coverage, a 4% match and 1,760 billed hours.
At the same rate, W2 is usually worth more because the agency pays half of Social Security and Medicare. A 1099 contractor pays 15.3% self employment tax but can deduct business expenses.
To break even, a 1099 contractor often needs about 1.4 to 1.6 times the employee’s hourly wage, depending on benefits, time off and gaps. Many aim higher to come out clearly ahead.
1099 contractors aren’t covered by federal overtime rules. Hourly W2 contract workers are usually non exempt agency employees and get time and a half after 40 hours.
Usually employer health insurance, retirement matches, paid holidays and vacation, the employer half of payroll tax, unemployment insurance and workers’ comp. Benefits are about 30% of private employers’ compensation costs.
Related guides: how to set your freelance hourly rate, salary vs hourly and gross vs net pay.
The example uses illustrative benefits, expenses and unpaid weeks. Your results depend on your offers, state and tax situation. This guide is general information, not tax or legal advice.